What evidence do you need to challenge a rent increase?
Updated · 2 min read · By the Rentoren team
Short answer
To challenge a rent increase, give the tribunal rents for similar homes nearby (agreed rents are stronger than advertised ones), a photo of every room and the front of the property, room sizes or a rough floor plan, a list of what the landlord provides, and details and photos of any disrepair. Condition matters: damp, mould and outdated kitchens or bathrooms all lower the market rent.
Key points
- Comparable rents: same type of home, same number of bedrooms, close by.
- Agreed rents beat asking prices. Rightmove and Zoopla help, but actual lettings are stronger.
- A photo of each room, plus the outside.
- Disrepair is evidence: photograph it and say when you reported it.
- Don't count improvements you paid for: the tribunal ignores them.
Rents for similar homes
This is the core of your case. Find homes like yours in the same area, with the same number of bedrooms and the same type (flat, terraced house and so on), and note the rent, address or street, and date.
GOV.UK says evidence from actual agreed lettings is stronger than advertised rents, and both are stronger than housing association rents, old fair-rent decisions or Local Housing Allowance rates.
Published tribunal decisions are useful too: they show what the tribunal decided for similar homes nearby. Rentoren's free rent check shows you recent nearby decisions.
Photos and details of your home
- a recent photo of each room, showing as much of it as possible
- a photo of the front of the property
- room sizes, or a rough floor plan
- features and who provided them: heating, double glazing, carpets, curtains, appliances, furniture
- local amenities: transport, shops, schools
Disrepair and missing features
Market rent is for your home as it is, so problems lower it. Photograph damp, mould, broken fittings, poor insulation or an old kitchen or bathroom, and say when you reported them to your landlord. Copies of messages help.
If a problem can't be seen in photos, such as a heating system that keeps failing, describe it and ask the tribunal to inspect.
What the tribunal ignores
Improvements you paid for yourself, such as a kitchen you fitted, don't increase the rent. Damage you caused doesn't lower it. Your personal finances don't change the market rent either, though if paying the new rent would cause hardship, you can ask the tribunal to postpone when it starts.
Can someone prepare the evidence for me?
Yes. With Rentoren's File for me service, you send photos and your notice from your phone, and we prepare the application and the rent evidence, send it to the tribunal and your landlord, and deal with the tribunal for you.
Common questions
Can I use Rightmove listings as evidence?
Yes. Information from letting agents or sites such as Rightmove and Zoopla can help, but GOV.UK says evidence from actual agreed lettings is stronger.
How many comparable properties do I need?
There's no set number. A handful of genuinely similar homes nearby is more convincing than many loosely similar ones.
Does disrepair reduce the rent the tribunal sets?
It can. The tribunal values your home in its actual condition, so disrepair and missing features usually mean a lower market rent.